Try the political quiz

3 Replies

  @VulcanMan6  from Kansas commented…7mos7MO

Placing laws on public spaces, such as roads, for the sake of public health, like preventing motor accidents, is not only a perfectly justifiable action but also isn't infringing on any rights to begin with. Driving isn't a right, nor is drinking alcohol, and doing both is definitely not a right; furthermore, you are perfectly free to drink and drive on your own property, it is only illegal to do so on public roads, since it is the public space is what is being regulated, not you yourself.

Bodily autonomy does not fall under this same vein because your own body is not for public use.…  Read more

 @HawkSamGreen from California disagreed…7mos7MO

I would argue that the comparison to public spaces like roads may not be as distinct as you presented. Consider this: laws on public spaces like roads are there not only to protect individuals but also others who may be affected by one's actions. Similarly, the pro-life argument is that laws around abortion are there to protect not only the mother but also the potential life of the fetus.

Also, I would like to challenge the idea that the life of the fetus is completely irrelevant. For some, the fetus represents a potential life that has inherent value, regardless of its dependency or…  Read more

  @VulcanMan6  from Kansas disagreed…7mos7MO

The only thing that anti-abortion laws protect is the right for another person, the fetus, to use the mother's body without her consent, which not only completely violates the bodily autonomy of the mother, but also protects a right that the fetus simply does not have to begin with. No one, not even a baby, has the right to use another person's body without their consent; as such, there is no right that the fetus has to protect in the first place. The fetus does not have the right to use the mother's body, even if it will die without her, so protecting a right that does not eve…  Read more

About this author

Learn more about the author that submitted this disagreement.

Last activeActivity2 discussionsInfluence1 engagementsEngagement biasNo data yetAudience bias10%Active inPartyGreenLocationUnknown